“I can’t figure out when to use が instead of は when the verb is あげます/くれます or もらいます. “

こんにちは!ちか先生(せんせい)です。
Konnichiwa! It’s Chika sensei.

Today I share my reply to a student’s question in the JLPT All-in-One course.
Students can ask questions in the comments section for all lessons.

==================

JLPT N5
あげます/くれます/もらいます|(receiving and giving)

[A student’s comment]

Chika-sensei,

My questions are related to lesson 16.
1. it is explained [giver] は/が [recipient]に[noun]をあげます/くれます.
2. It is explained [recipient] は/が [recipient]に/から[noun]をもらいます.

I can’t figure out when to use が instead of は when the verb is あげます/くれます or もらいます. And I can’t figure out when to use から instead of に when the verb is もらいます.

Thank you for your help,

 



[Chika Sensei’s reply]

は、が
In this “receiving and giving verb” grammar, が is used to emphasize the giver or the recipient. (When the giver or the recipient is the main topic of discussion.)

e.g.
A:だれこのとけいをくれましたか。
B:ともだちくれました。
main topic=だれ、ともだち
Emphasize the givers.

A:たなかさんなにをくれましたか。
B:とけいをくれました。
main topic=なに、とけい

 

に、から
In this “receiving and giving verb” grammar, you can think of them as basically the same.
To be exact, に is used only for people, but から can be used for organizations.

×がっこう本をもらいました。
がっこうから本をもらいました。

==================

 

The teacher’s comments will be in easy to understand Japanese or English according to your level.
You can ask any questions like, “How do you say this in Japanese?”, “What’s the difference between these two words?” etc.
The teacher explains to you until you are satisfied.

 

 

 

————————————————-
Do you want to pass the next JLPT?

The “JLPT All-in-One course” covers all the JLPT subjects(Grammar, Listening, Reading, Vocabulary, and Mock test), you will pass the JLPT.
There are over 300 lessons at each level, and with daily reminders from Chika Sensei, you will be able to complete them all without difficulty.

N5, N4, N3, N2, and N1 courses are available!

JLPT prep in 10 minutes a day.
Our quick lessons allow busy people to have time to study for the JLPT.
You won’t be left behind with personalized support.

Click here to select your level>>