Particle が vs に (ga vs ni) :JLPT Grammar

[Student’s sentence]

 

母は兄が医者になってほしいようだ。
My mother seems to want my elder brother to become a doctor.

*はははあにがいしゃになってほしいようだ。

 






 

[My correction]

 

母は兄医者になってほしいようだ。
→母は兄医者になってほしいようだ。
My mother seems to want my elder brother to become a doctor.

 

The correct answer is B: に

 

〜てほしい typically follows the structure [person]に[verb in te-form]ほしい.
Since 医者になる is a fixed phrase, we convert it into te-form as a whole, resulting in [あに]に[医者になって]ほしい. The particle に appearing twice is not an issue, as each serves a different function.

 

Examples:

夫(おっと)は娘(むすめ)歌手(かしゅ)になってほしくないそうです。
My husband does not want our daughter to become a singer.

 

息子(むすこ)私(わたし)の会社(かいしゃ)の社長(しゃちょう)になってほしいとは思(おも)っていません。
I do not wish for my son to become the president of my company.

 

In the JLPT course, each lesson includes homework. Submit your homework, and I’ll provide corrections. I’ll break down Japanese grammar, highlighting mistakes and explaining structures and nuances in a simple way. Feel free to ask as many questions as you need—I’m here to help you understand!